“The right to live with your family is not a right that attaches to citizenship when immigration laws are in question.”
That is how Professor Helena Wray, an immigration-law scholar and co-leader of the Brexit Couples research project, explained one of Brexit’s consequences when I interviewed her. It is a startling thought for a country that spent years talking about taking back control: some British citizens discovered they could not easily live in Britain with the person they loved.
Before Brexit, an EU citizen working, studying or supporting themselves could generally settle in Britain under EU free-movement law. Their right to stay did not depend on their British partner. Many people already living in the UK retained comparable protections through the EU Settlement Scheme. But couples who missed that route now face Britain’s family immigration rules, unless they qualify for another visa.
Professor Helena Wray (Photo Credit, Farah ALHashem)
The usual income threshold for sponsoring a partner is £29,000 a year. Wray estimates that visa applications and associated charges can exceed £12,000 over the normal five-year route to permanent settlement. Some couples in her research never applied because they could not meet the requirements. Even a successful application usually means renewals every two and a half years, no access to public funds for the migrant partner and a status that remains dependent on the relationship until settlement. Others described the rules as “an assault on their citizenship.”
Britain voted for more national control. Yet for these citizens, sovereignty meant less control over where they could build a family. And this was not a restriction invented for European partners: non-EU families had been dealing with it for years. Brexit simply brought more people under the same system.
Has Britain’s argument with Europe always concealed another, more personal argument: who actually gets to belong?
On June 23, 2016, 17.4 million people voted to leave the European Union. Britain formally withdrew on Jan. 31, 2020. Ten years after the referendum, more Britons believe leaving was a mistake and Prime Minister Andy Burnham is pursuing closer ties with the EU. But what, exactly, do they want back?
This post is for paying subscribers only
Sign up now and upgrade your account to read the post and get access to the full library of posts for paying subscribers only.